Barenaked Ladies: Jane
Billboard Top 100 = No! (though it did hit #3 in Canada in 1994): Lyrics = A+, Music = B, Memories = C, GPA = 3.11.
We continue our study of ballads by reviewing "Jane" by the Barenaked Ladies (listen to a snipped here, from Amazon.com).
Remember, when we reviewed "Picture Postcards From LA" by Joshua Kadison, we noted that all ballads must have an "inflection point" in order to be discussed on Life 'n Lyrics. Jane fits this criteria perfectly!
Let's begin our study of the song.
The girl works at the store, sweet Jane St. Clair
Was dazzled by her smile while I shopped there
It wasn't long before I lived with her
I sang her songs while she dried my hair
Well, this Jane person sounds nice, with a nice smile. I'm thinking that the person who wrote this song omitted a few things between her smile and the fact that he somehow ended up living with her, but we'll give this transgression a pass.
And then, the tone changes a bit.
Jane, divided, but I can't decide which side I'm on
Jane decided only cowards stay, while traitors run
Jane, Jane
Why is Jane divided? What's up with traitors, anyway? Did men mistreat Jane in the past?
The next verse offers the inflection point.
I'd bring her gold and frankincense and myrrh
She thought that I was making fun of her
She made me feel I was fourteen again
That's why she thinks it's cooler if we'd just stay friends
Jane, Jane
What?
Any guy who has been in love knows what it is like to feel fourteen again in the presence of a woman. The song hits a high point at that very lyric. And then, BAM, the bottom falls out of the song.
Jane doesn't think a man could ever be faithful
Jane isn't giving me a chance to be shameful
So did Jane cut this relationship short, or did the guy who wrote this song give clues about forthcoming transgressions?
Now you're playing defense, and that's never going to turn out the way you want it to turn out.
I wrote a letter, she should have got it yesterday
That life could be better by being together
Is what I cannot explain to Jane
That's the big advantage to being married. Somehow, you break through that invisible wall. For whatever reason, she agrees that life could be better by being together. Who knows what causes that switch to flip?
The girl works at the store, sweet Jane St. Clair
Still dazzled by her smile while I shoplift there
No promises as vague as Heaven
No Juliana next to my Evan
Jane, desired by the people at her school and work
Jane is tired, 'cause every man becomes a lovesick jerkJane, Jane
We leave with the revelation that Jane is one attractive lady, a woman who has been burned over and over again by various Men. Men! What's wrong with us?
Once again, we're dazzled by a ballad, a ballad that is defined by an inflection point. All great ballads possess this wonderful attribute!
